Monday, October 15, 2007

Are "Green" guitars plausible?

Posted by Jon

Blog Action Day
As it is Blog Action Day I decided to do a special post about what Guitar Companies can and are doing to help the environment.

We all know that the rainforests in Brazil are being harvested so rapidly that it is driving some species of trees to extinction, well one of these species is Brazillian Rosewood one of the finest materials for building guitars. In Australia, and in many parts of our world, 70+% of our forest cover has been removed in less than 200 years (reference).

The question is, what can be done about this? Do luthiers need to switch to using composite materials? Is carbon-fibre the only alternative? Well some people seem to think this isn’t necessarily the only answer. Cole Clark guitars here in Australia are promoting use of a timber called Bunya which is similar to Spruce and is used for soundboards on acoustic guitars and puts on a good amount of biomass each year, is relatively quick growing, good for absorbing carbon, bears edible fruit and has strong links to Australia’s indigenous people. Maton also use Bunya as well as a few other native species such as Queensland Maple.

Ellis Guitars in Western Australia have been Certified by the Forest Stewardship Council and has the following statements on their site:

Taking responsibility for forest management by protecting biodiversity, productivity and ecological processes.
Taking responsibility socially helping both local people and society in the long term. Educating local people on the benefits of sustaining natural resources.
Taking responsibility economically structuring operations so profit is not at the expense of natural resources or locals.

And this responsibility by luthiers is the key. Taylor Guitars are trying to dedicate a forest in Alaska for musical wood, something they are working toward along with Gibson, Martin, Fender, Greenpeace, the Forestry Stewardship Council and Sealaska (a Native American logging company). This would provide US guitar makers with a sustainable resource that is responsibly managed, far more appealing than moving logging to a new country and ravaging their supplies. Meanwhile 80-90% of Gibson’s regular production electric guitars contain mostly SmartWood-certified wood, SmartWood is one of the certifiers endorsed by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Rainforest Alliance.

Taylor says guitar manufacturers know the woods that sound good and that don’t - there is no new miracle wood out there. So in lieu of using less traditional woods they are working on buying from more and more ecologically responsible forestry companies.“ - via GearWire

Apart from using sustainable materials some companies are taking a new approach. For instance Wheatware guitar picks which were used at this years Live Earth event. These picks are “Bio-Compostable products are designed to biodegrade in 45 to 90 days in microbially-active soil or a commercial compost facility“, this production doesn’t impact on the Wheat supply either. Meanwhile Composite Acoustics...have replaced traditional materials with carbon fiber - a man-made composite that is stronger, lighter and more consistent“. You only have to read their Advantage section on their site to see they truly believe in great sounding carbon fibre instruments, but many purists will simply reject these guitars in favour of natural materials so don’t expect the current generation of guitarists to start switching just yet. Aside from taking a drastic approach to materials some companies are helping out with their packaging, I spoke to Dean Markley recently and he had this to say: “...our packaging is Environmentally friendly. Some of the packaging is made from recycled material and all of the packaging can be recycled.“.

So are “Green” guitars plausible? Yes, it means guitar companies need to take responsibility something that has obviously been happening for a while now, and for customers to be educated on instruments made from sustainable woods. These customers just need to realise that sustainable woods can sound just as good as traditional materials.

Recently on Guitar Noize

Tony Hogan on 10/15 at 06:15 PM

A very sensible article.  Agreed, we need to make guitars from sustainable timbers.  I love the story about Linda Manzer finding a log on the beach that she built a guitar for the great Canadian guitarist Bruce Cockburn.

Jon on 10/15 at 08:12 PM

Thanks Tony, I’m not very good at writing serious articles so I’m glad someone has taken the time to read it smile
I’ve never heard that story about Linda Manzer, thats great I’ll have to look that one up!

Rebecca M on 10/16 at 07:33 AM

Thanks for a great post that combined both the theme of your blog and the theme of Blog Action Day!  I didn’t try to do that, but now I wish I had! grin

RecycleCindy on 10/16 at 09:24 AM

Great post for Blog Action Day. Thanks so much for your support for our environment.

on 10/16 at 02:22 PM

Thanks I was glad to do my bit, even if it was in a very small way… every little helps!

clairec23 on 10/16 at 08:17 PM

That was the most unique blog action day post I’ve read.  Great stuff!  I tried to look at all of the links in the discussion you started on blogcatalog but I forgot about yours til just now smile

on 10/16 at 08:46 PM

Thanks for stopping by and reading, I’m glad you found it interesting.

Jamie Nelson on 10/21 at 04:36 AM

CA Guitars are great.  I had a Bluegrass Performer for a couple of years that I loved, then I decided I wanted electronics, so I traded it in on a Legacy Performer a year ago.  The great thing about them is they aren’t effected by humidity and temp.  They hold their tuning like no other.  They are very durable too.  I hardly ever even use the case as it is more prone to damage than the guitar itself.  I take it in and out of buildings in the harsh winters of Wisconsin and it’s ready to play.

on 10/21 at 09:49 PM

I have to say Jamie they look very impressive on the website, I’d certainly like to give them a try. I like the fact they are not affected by humidity!

“I hardly ever even use the case as it is more prone to damage than the guitar itself” - thats brilliant, what a great ad for CA Guitars!!

on 11/22 at 03:05 AM

Godin Guitars up here in Canada are very environmentally friendly.  They use very high quality wood which is also sustainably harvested.  Everything is made in Canada so that means less shipping if you live in N.A. vs an operation across the pond. 

Plus the value is incredible.  I picked up a Simon & Patrick Pro Flame Maple (Godin has many different lines of guitars).  It was under a thousand dollars Canadian (at the beginning of 2007) and it looks and sounds amazing.  It sounds better than some guitars twice the price that I’ve played.

Page 1 of 1 pages

Post a comment

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.