Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Notion Progression TAB Software

Posted by Jon in • Guitar Software

Notion Progression
When it comes to writing down your latest creation most of us would probably scribble a few chords on a scrap of paper and hope we can remember it the next time or if it is for someone else… well just hope for the best or supply a recording with it. The more adventurous guitarists out there might actually write it down in TAB notation either on paper or in ASCII in your favourite text editor (a very tedious task!). I have come from a background of using Steinberg Cubase first on an Atari ST520 and then VST on PC and there were basic scoring features in these programs but it didn’t translate to Guitar. So I was really excited to get my hands on Progression by Notion Music.

Notion Music specialise in Music Scoring software, their flagship product Notion 2.0 uses samples of the London Symphony Orchestra recorded at Abbey Road Studios for authentic playback instead of nasty MIDI instruments. Progression also uses sampled sounds in order to make it easier to get realistic sounding scores but they are specifically tailored to Guitarists needs. For a start you have a choice of Guitars and Basses, Keyboards and Harps and a Drum Kit. Ok say you choose an electric guitar, lets face it that is where most of us start and you drag a couple of notes onto the stave or tab to see how it sounds. It sounds like a clean guitar, obviously. But, and this is where Progression is really different from normal TAB software, you have 3 FX banks per instrument. If you open FX1 you have a choice of amps, a speaker simulator, Chorus, Delay and Reverb units. There are also lots of presets from Clean to Rock and you can modify any of the parameters by changing the settings on the effects units or by adding and removing effects modules very easily.

Now the real job of this software is to notate your compositions so how do we do that. Well there are 3 methods. The first and primary method is using a MIDI guitar, something that unfortunately I don’t own and therefore couldn’t test but I think this is where this software would really shine. The second method is using a MIDI keyboard ,alas again which is something I don’t own. So I had to use the 3rd and quite frankly least preferable method of drag and drop. Now I’m not a very patient person so I found this pretty tricky. I knew what I wanted to do but it seemed a bit of a chore to actually do it. My advice is use a keyboard if you have one, but a MIDI guitar would be a lot easier. Saying that when you see what can be achieved with a little patience and know how in the demo files it is pretty impressive and you could use it create jam tracks using the built in drum sample tracks and throw some chord progressions in there. The only thing I was a bit disappointed about was that you can’t convert the chord diagrams to TAB, this would be a nice addition for quickly creating tracks.

I am going to have to put in some time in to see if I can learn how to create notation with minimum effort and no external MIDI input device. That said, this is an incredibly powerful software application if you are prepared to take the time to learn. Teachers in particular will probably find this indispensible once they use it. If you just wanted to notate scales and chord changes it is actually really easy there is a Chord diagram section at the bottom of the application where you choose the key and it shows all the chord variations which you can drag and drop into your score, these are visual elements only. If you want to TAB a C Major scale you can click on the strings in the TAB and type the fret number into the box that appears, very simple. And I suppose if you start out with these tasks you will slowly start expanding on your knowledge and start creating multi-voice multi-instrument scores in no time.

Jason on 10/17 at 10:38 AM

Hey Jon.

When I first heard about the new Progression, I was quick to judge it.  I believe I didn’t read a complete review on it and I compared it to Power Tab and said Power Tab was better and free.  But with all the features you name, it doesn’t even sound like the same thing.

I even bashed Progression and had the creator show up replying that I didn’t know what I was talking about.  I guess I didn’t. 

Sounds like some pretty sweet software.

See ya.

Jon on 10/17 at 11:14 AM

I forgot to mention in my review that I was looking for Mac specific software which ruled out Power Tab but I had used that in the past on PC and the MIDI soundbanks really annoy me when you play it back, its really nice how Progression allows you to emulate the guitar sound that you want and therefore helps you to make sure the Tab is as accurate as possible. If you have a clean MIDI sound you might not get the sustain that you need and therefore think you have tabbed it incorrectly or something?

I recommend at least giving the demo a try and see what you think.

Tony hogan on 10/17 at 04:40 PM

Jon

Hopefully you’ll keep us up to date with the developments.  As a musician, music educationalist and composer I’m always interested in tools to make my job easier. There comes a time when most musicians realize that although some of the freebies out there are good and can take you so far, investing in professional tools is extremely useful and can save a lot of time.

TH

James on 10/17 at 08:25 PM

What’s the state of midi pickups now? Can you buy a cheapish, easy to install pickup and clip it on? Or are there any jack to MIDI boxes? (Doesn’t OSX have some good in-built MIDI capabilities to help with this?). Not sure what the state-of-the-art is.

Oh, and you have got a MIDI keyboard, you just left it on the other side of the world!

Jon on 10/17 at 08:48 PM

Well you could go for Fender’s new VG strat which has a Roland MIDI pickup built in and lets you switch tunings and sounds at the flick of a switch but that will set you back 1300 of your english pounds or for a 100 pounds you can get a Roland GK3 which is pretty reasonable I think? I’ve never used a MIDI pickup so I have no idea how good they are but the GK3 has a few installation options included double sided tape, very Blue Peter!

I’m not sure how you plug a MIDI guitar into a Mac? I’ll look into it, by the way have you seen the unimaginatively named iAxe by Behringer? http://www.behringer.com/IAXE393 its a USB guitar!

As for the MIDI keyboard, yeah I know… wonder if I should ship it out?!

Jon on 10/17 at 08:58 PM

Ok seems I was being a little optimistic, looks like you need the Roland GI-20 MIDI interface as well as the pickup which means another 300 quid, but that connects using USB so it would be easy to plug in to your mac.

Mark Starlin on 10/20 at 09:23 AM

Any music software is a bit tediuos when it comes to note entry. Even if you have a MIDI keyboard you need to play PERFECTLY (or clean up your mistakes afterwards) or else step the notes and chords in one at a time. As a guitar teacher I use Sibelius, which is too expensive for casual users or TAB only guys, but it allows you to type the note name (E for example) using the keyboard while you select note duration (quarter note, etc.) using the numeric keypad. This is relatively quick, especially for us guitarists who don’t excel at keyboards. However, you need to know your notes on the neck (unfortunately, many guitarists don’t.) But you can convert the TAB staff to standard notation or standard notation to TAB with the click of the option key. Very nice!

It looks like Progression has a fretboard you can use to enter notes. Is this correct? That should help non-readers. Ideally, progression would help non-readers learn to read standard notation - the language of music. And honestly, every “musician” should be able to read music, in my opinion.  It is really not that hard to learn if you can count to 12.

Anyway, Progression looks very similiar to Sibelius G7.

on 10/21 at 09:47 PM

Hi Mark, yes Progression does have a fretboard which you can use which is a helpful feature but I find typing in the fret numbers probably the easiest, this entails choosing a note length (either with a keyboard shortcut or by clicking on it) then you click on a string in the TAB and type in a fret number, a relatively painless process.

I know every musician should be able to read music, but some can’t but might want to just TAB some basic chord changes, this would in my opinion give some real reference to standard notation and definitely help teach guitarists to read music.

Jon on 10/22 at 12:07 PM

I just found this review of Progression over at http://www.mustech.net/ which might also be useful to people.

Kyle Poehling on 10/24 at 05:16 AM

Great review!

I’ve had an absolute BLAST working on developing Progression...it truly has changed quite a bit about my ability to “compose on the fly.”

A few things we’re working on over here (at Notion):
-Midi-input should be working well (both coming from a midi-keyboard or a midi-guitar pickup) by the first update.

-The “Chord Library” should enter the actual chord when (instead of just placing the tab symbol above the staff).

-VSTI (the ability to use external sound libraries) should be ironed out.

-Video tutorials and lessons will be up on the site within a few weeks.

Hope this helps! Thanks again and great review!
Kyle Poehling

on 10/24 at 12:52 PM

Hi Kyle thanks for stopping by and giving us some updates, the Chord Library will be a great addition that will really speed up TAB-ing a song, look forward to seeing the video tutorials too they will be very useful for beginners like me.

Page 1 of 1 pages

Post a comment

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.